Should You Take Career Advice from ChatGPT? (Or Anyone Else?)

Nov 19, 2026By Carmel Drake
Carmel Drake

You're thinking about changing career.

You mention it to your partner. "Are you losing your mind? We need your salary to make ends meet".

You tell a friend. "You've been unhappy for ages! Life's too short. Go for it!"

You confide in a colleague. "Really? But you've worked so hard to get where you are. Why would you leave now?"

Three people. Three different opinions.

And perhaps you're no clearer than when you started.

So you turn to ChatGPT.

You explain your situation, outline your options and ask what it thinks.

Within seconds, you have a thoughtful, well-structured response. It acknowledges your concerns, weighs up the possibilities and suggests a way forward.

It sounds very reasonable.

But is it good advice?

Everyone sees your situation through a different lens

When someone gives you career advice, they're not simply evaluating your circumstances.

They're also bringing their own experiences, beliefs and priorities into the conversation.

Your partner might be particularly concerned about money because you're the breadwinner. And that's a perfectly legitimate consideration.

Your friend might encourage you to take a risk because leaving a secure job was the best decision they ever made.

Your colleague might genuinely believe you're making a mistake. Perhaps they've spent their entire career working towards the kind of position you're now considering leaving.

None of them is necessarily wrong.

I've noticed how easily conversations about career decisions can become conversations about what someone else would do.

If I were you, I'd...

But they're not you.

They don't necessarily have the same priorities, responsibilities, appetite for risk or ideas about what makes a satisfying working life.

Which doesn't mean you should ignore them. Someone else's perspective can be enormously valuable, particularly when they have experience or knowledge that you don't.

But I'd want to understand where their advice was coming from before deciding how much weight to give it.

Can you trust career advice from ChatGPT?

AI adds another interesting dimension.

I use AI myself and can often be heard extolling its virtues. 

It can help you research unfamiliar industries, explore different career paths, compare options and identify questions you hadn't thought to ask.

It's also available in your pocket whenever you want it. You don't need to arrange a conversation or worry about whether you're taking up someone's time.

And there's something appealing about asking a question without feeling judged.

But how much should you trust the answers?

By now, most of us are familiar with ChatGPT's tendency to be rather agreeable. You present an idea and it tells you it's a great one. You express a concern and it validates your feelings. Sometimes that's helpful. Sometimes it's precisely what you don't need.

There's research behind this, too. A study published in Science earlier this year found that AI models affirmed users' actions considerably more often than human respondents in the situations tested.

But what interests me more in the context of career decisions is how much the answer can depend on the question.

Imagine typing:

I've been unhappy at work for months. My manager doesn't appreciate me, I'm exhausted and I think I need to leave. What would you suggest?

Now imagine asking:

I've been feeling dissatisfied at work recently, but I'm not sure whether it's the job, my manager or something else. Can you help me explore what's going on?

Same situation. Same person. But very different starting points for the conversation.

The first already contains a conclusion: my manager doesn't appreciate me and I probably need to leave.

Of course, a good AI response might challenge that assumption rather than reinforce it. But it might not.

And if it comes back with a thoughtful, convincing explanation of why leaving sounds sensible, how do you know whether it's identified something important or simply followed the direction you've already pointed it in?

Are we sometimes looking for advice that confirms what we think?

Of course, ChatGPT isn't the only source of advice that might tell us what we want to hear.

Friends do it too.

Sometimes because they want to be supportive. Sometimes because they don't want to upset us. And sometimes because we've told our story in a way that makes one conclusion seem almost inevitable.

Imagine telling a friend about everything that's gone wrong at work over the past six months.

They listen sympathetically and eventually say, "You really need to get out of there."

Perhaps they're right.

But perhaps they haven't heard about the parts of your job you still enjoy. Or the opportunities available within your organisation. Or the financial commitments that make leaving complicated.

And I wonder whether we're always completely unaware of this.

Sometimes, if we're honest with ourselves, we know which friend is likely to tell us to take the risk and which one will encourage us to be cautious. And perhaps that influences who we choose to ask in the first place.

The same may be true when we turn to AI. The way we phrase a question, the details we include and the ones we leave out can all influence the response we receive.

That doesn't make the advice worthless. But it's worth noticing how much of the story the other person - or the AI - has actually heard.

Equally, someone who challenges your thinking isn't automatically giving better advice.

A blunt opinion isn't necessarily an informed one.

For me, the question isn't simply whether someone agrees or disagrees with you.

It's whether their contribution helps you understand your situation more accurately.

How to decide whose career advice to trust

If you're facing an important career decision, I'd start by thinking about the kind of help you actually need.

If you're considering moving into a new industry, someone who works in that industry may be able to tell you about opportunities, working conditions and the realities of particular roles.

If you're worried about the financial implications of leaving your job, a qualified financial adviser may be more useful than a friend who happens to be good with money.

If you're trying to understand why you're dissatisfied despite having what looks like an excellent job, that may call for a different kind of conversation altogether.

Not every person needs to answer every question.

And I'd pay attention to three things when evaluating advice.

1. What does this person actually know?

Are they speaking from relevant experience? Do they understand your circumstances? Are they offering facts you can check, or opinions based on their own preferences?

2. What assumptions are they making?

Someone advising you to stay might be prioritising security. Someone encouraging you to leave might place more importance on independence or variety.

Neither priority is inherently better. But are they yours?

3. What is missing from the conversation?

What haven't you told them? What might they not have considered? And what would someone with a completely different perspective say?

I think these questions are just as relevant when the advice comes from ChatGPT.

In fact, one of the most useful ways to use AI may be to ask it not to give you advice straight away.

Instead of asking, "Should I leave my job?", try:

"I'm considering a career decision. Before suggesting what I should do, ask me questions to understand my circumstances. Challenge my assumptions, identify information I'm missing and help me consider alternative explanations. Don't simply agree with me."

That doesn't guarantee an objective response. But it gives the conversation a rather different starting point.

And if AI gives you factual information about salaries, qualifications or employment opportunities, I'd verify it with reliable sources before making decisions based on it.

Sometimes you don't need more advice

There's another possibility worth considering.

Perhaps what you need isn't another opinion at all.

If you've already spoken to friends, family and colleagues, researched your options and asked ChatGPT, you may have plenty of information. What you might be missing is an opportunity to examine it all without someone else telling you what they think you should do.

It's one of the reasons I think coaching can be so useful when you're facing a difficult decision.

At least as I was trained to practise it, coaching isn't about giving advice. I'm not there to tell someone whether they should leave their job, apply for a promotion or change direction entirely.

I might question an assumption, notice a contradiction or ask about something they seem to be avoiding. 

But I'm not there to substitute my judgement for theirs.

I've written before about how to choose a coach and what to look for before deciding, including why the right coach isn't necessarily someone who agrees with you or makes you feel comfortable.

Of course, I bring my own experiences and perspectives into the conversation. We all do. My responsibility is to be aware of those influences and create as impartial and non-judgemental a space as possible for someone to examine their own thinking.

That doesn't mean agreeing with everything they say. Far from it.

Sometimes the most useful part of a coaching conversation is being asked a question you'd rather not answer.

But the aim isn't to persuade someone towards a particular decision. It's to help them see their situation more clearly and reach a decision they can stand behind.

If you're facing a career decision and would value that kind of conversation, I'd be happy to explore it with you. I offer a free 30-minute discovery call where we can talk about what's going on, what you're trying to work out and whether coaching might be useful.

Book a free 30-minute discovery call.

You can ask a hundred people what they'd do in your situation.

But none of them has to live with your decision.

You do.